We Found Marion’s History-Making Pumpkin Spice Cake

We’re resurrecting a little slice of American cake history with this very vintage homemade pumpkin spice layer cake recipe slathered with fresh pumpkin butter custard frosting, oh way. It might even awaken something meaningful for you the way that autumn spice aromas can tug mysteriously at our hearts. Continue reading

Rejuvenating Dr. Chase’s Home Hearth Pumpkin Butter Recipe

pumpkin-cider-butter-overhead-by-bake this cake

We’ve been chasing down Dr. Chase and the lumberjacks in the North Woods with their slow simmering pumpkin butter to bring you this mellow pumpkin jam recipe. It will warm your heart and your home as it slow cooks with spiced apple cider and winter weather spices. Continue reading

Grandma Margaret’s Buttery Coconut Cream Cake Recipe

Homemade Coconut Cream Cake with fresh berries by bake this cake

This golden cream of coconut cake, modified over decades in our family from a 1924 recipe, is frosted with vanilla custard frosting and sprinkled with sweetened coconut flakes. Continue reading

Crazy Cool Century-Old Coffee Cake Recipe

tasting vintage german coffee cake by bake this cake

We’re fast-stepping our way through prep time of this old-fashioned yeasted coffee cake with a couple of 30-second finger-kneading sessions to let the yeast do all the work. Then we’ll drizzle it with icing and serve it warm from the oven. Hello homemade! Continue reading

Who Knew Real Red Velvet Cake Was Not Even Red #waitwhat

Vintage natural brown red velvet cake with no red food coloring by bakethiscake

If you’re looking for red, you won’t find it here. But if you’re looking for old-fashioned cocoa cake flavor in a moist (brown) red velvet cake layered with classic vanilla custard frosting, well then, you’ve come to the right place! Continue reading

Boozy Top Tier Dinner Party Cake

Chocolate Wine Cake by bake this cake

Presenting our trending top-tier cake for your next dinner party! It’s not actually boozy or even boozy tasting. It’s just that its made with wine (and the boozy word looks good in the title). Okay, it does have a splash … Continue reading

Grandma’s Heavenly Heart Cake

Homemade Gingerbread on a silver fork with raspberry and creme fraiche by bake this cake

Everyone should have a Mother’s Gingerbread Cake recipe on hand, don’t you think?  And there are a lot of them out there. I know because we’ve tried nearly every one we can lay a hand on, starting from recipes created … Continue reading

Easy Homemade Almond Coffee Biscotti Recipe

Homemade mini biscotti recipe dipped in dark chocolate by bake this cake

We’re kicking up the flavor and texture quotient of this classic little coffee snack by throwing our brittle biscotto to the wind!  Cause this here’s a buttery and brunchy biscuit cookie (not a dry or crusty breadstick). And it’s loaded full-bore … Continue reading